Back to Legacy

Hadith studies

How hadith were assessed

What the isnad and matn tell us, why transmitters’ lives mattered, and how scholars compared versions.

Geometric ornament on the interior of the mosque dome

The text and its chain of transmission

A hadith is a report about the Prophet Muhammad’s words, actions or approvals. In a recorded hadith, the matn is the wording of the report and the isnad is the chain of people through whom it reached the compiler.

The isnad allows a researcher to trace a report’s origins. Two accounts with similar wording may come through different transmitters. A difference in one name can change how the chain is evaluated.

Establishing a link

Al-Bukhari investigated where and when transmitters lived, who taught them, and whom they met. Evidence that a transmitter had met the person from whom they received a report mattered when assessing the chain.

Scholars also considered each transmitter’s reputation and the accuracy of their memory or records. Gathering this information was a field of study in its own right.

Comparing versions

Different chains for the same report reveal which details recur and where accounts diverge. Comparison can bring to light a mistaken name or a change in wording. Scholars examined such differences in the context of how the reports were transmitted.

Lives of the transmitters

Al-Bukhari gathered information about transmitters’ teachers, pupils, lifetimes and scholarly connections. His Al-Tarikh al-Kabir, or The Great History, helps readers study that network and shows how biographical research complements hadith collections.

Sources and further reading